October 28, 2020

Concierge Medicine Today | For Doctors Forum

A Community in Healthcare Where Experienced Doctors Can Learn What's Working, Trade Notes & Network | Est. 2007 | This site does not constitute medical or legal advice | National-International Education & News | Industry Trade Publication

Trending Today … ‘Evidence About Whether Retail Medical Clinics Disrupt Doctor-Patient Relationships Is Mixed’

3 min read

A new RAND Corporation study examining the impact of retail medical clinics on the receipt of primary medical care finds mixed evidence about whether the clinics may disrupt doctor-patient relationships.

The study found that people who visit retail medical clinics are less likely to return to a primary care physician for future illnesses and have less continuity of care. However, there was no evidence retail medical clinics disrupted preventive medical care or management of diabetes, two important measures of quality of primary care.

The findings, published online by the Journal of General Internal Medicine, are the first to provide insight about how the growing number of retail medical clinics may affect doctor-patient relationships and use of primary care services.

“There is concern whether retail clinics may disrupt the relationship between patients and their personal physicians, which may make it difficult to maintain the quality and continuity of medical care,” said senior author Dr. Ateev Mehrotra, an associate professor at the University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine and a researcher at RAND, a nonprofit research organization. “We found use of retail clinics did have a negative impact on some aspects of primary care.”

RAND researchers have documented the rapid rise of retail clinics, which now number more than 1,300 nationally. Use of the clinics increased 10-fold from 2007 to 2009 among those with commercial health insurance, with use projected to rise more in the future. The walk-in clinics typically are staffed by nurse practitioners and offer basic types of health care with clearly posted prices.

Researchers examined the link between retail clinics and use of primary care providers by examining the records of a large group of people with commercial health insurance who used a retail medical clinic for an acute medical condition during 2008. Researchers examined their medical care a year before the visit and a year afterward, comparing their patterns of care with those patients who visited a primary care physician for an acute health problem during the same period.

People who visited a retail medical clinic for one of 11 common ailments such as a respiratory infection or urinary tract infection were less likely over the next 12 months to visit a primary care physician the next time they needed similar care. Patients who visited retail clinics also had less continuity of care, such as seeing the same physician for their medical needs.

Mehrotra said since the use of retail clinics was not associated with less preventive care or poorer management of diabetes, it’s hard to make an overall assessment about the impact that the use of retail clinics had on the quality primary care.

“The interpretation of our findings depends on one’s view about the relative importance of different aspects of primary care,” said study author Rachel O. Reid of the University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine. “Retail clinics are still in their infancy and over time we may or may not observe a more negative impact of retail clinics on preventive care or continuity of medical care.”

Support for the study was provided by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation’s Changes in Health Care Financing and Organization Initiative. Other authors of the study are J. Scott Ashwood of RAND and Carnegie Mellon University, Dr. Mark W. Friedberg of RAND and the Harvard Medical School, Ellerie S. Weber of the University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine and Carnegie Mellon University, and Claude M. Setodji of RAND.

RAND Health, a division of the RAND Corporation, is the nation’s largest independent health policy research program, with a broad research portfolio that focuses on health care costs, quality and public health preparedness, among other topics.

1 thought on “Trending Today … ‘Evidence About Whether Retail Medical Clinics Disrupt Doctor-Patient Relationships Is Mixed’

  1. Negative impact on Primary Care? Really? So Retail Clinics are NOT giving primary care services? Huh? The fact that they provide convenient, timely, relatively inexpensive care for routine problems that often affect patient in the day to day lives is, uh,uh, well I guess, I’m not sure… Oh, that’s right it RETAIL CARE! I keep forgetting.

    Excerpt #1: The study found that people who visit retail medical clinics are less likely to return to a primary care physician for future illnesses and have less continuity of care. However, there was no evidence retail medical clinics disrupted preventive medical care or management of diabetes, two important measures of quality of primary care.

    Here is the study headline:
    ‘Evidence About Whether Retail Medical Clinics Disrupt Doctor-Patient Relationships Is Mixed’

    Instead of a study to determine if Retail Medical Clinics “Disrupt” the Doctor-Patient Relationship, maybe we should be examining why our patients would RATHER go to a retail clinic that see us (their primary care doctors). Here are just a few of the reasons I hear from urgent care patients over the years as to why they come to the UC instead of their PCP ( substitute retail clinics for UC): # couldn’t get me in… # doesn’t do stitches anymore…. # doesn’t do x-rays in office…. # doesn’t take walk-in patients… # usually refers me to specialist for everything anyway…# won’t return my calls…

    Notice a pattern here? If I’ve heard any of these once complaints, I heard them a hundred times!

    Instead of viewing the status quo PCP model as the center of the universe, maybe we should take some plays from the Retail Clinic playbook before we become obsolete.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Copyright © All rights reserved. Newsphere by AF themes.
%d bloggers like this: