A Community in Healthcare Where Experienced Doctors Can Learn What's Working, Trade Notes & Network | Est. 2007 | This site does not constitute medical or legal advice | National-International Education & News | Industry Trade Publication
Subscribe Today
Welcome to Our DocPreneur Leadership Network
Watch New Healthcare Industry Edu Webinars, Live Chats, and Network w/ Your Peers in Our New Online Forum curated by CMT #FORDoctors, #FORNurses, #FORPAs ... (JOIN FREE HERE)
Save on Book Bundles (Free Shipping!)
NEW! 2021 Concierge Physician Reading List Released!
Monthly LIVE Webinar Event | Register Here!
Monthly Industry Networking Event | Live ZOOM Webinar ... (2nd Wed., Every Month!)
Healthcare Professional Edu.
Media Training Guide FOR Concierge Doctors
Click here FOR MORE ... and view a list of CMTs top tips, tools and strategies to help you talk to the media ....
JOIN Our Online Community
Industry Top Doc “Nominations” Open
Master Class: Webcam Confidence For Docs
JOIN THE PHYSICIAN DIRECTORY
FIND A DOCTOR NEAR YOU …
New Patient Checklist: 50 Questions (Download)
Our Best Selling Book Ever | Free Shipping!
NEW! Latest Edition - Over 700+ Pages of Education, Tips, Tools, Strategies and Insight Into Concierge Medicine and Building A Subscription-Based Healthcare Delivery Model ... LEARN MORE ...
2021 | Atlanta, GA USA | Annual Conference
Master Class: Media Relations Public Speaking Tool Kit
History of Concierge Medicine (1996-Present)
SHOP OUR RESOURCES & BOOKS ON SALE!
Join the New Online Physician Community!
What Is Concierge Medicine? Updated for 2021
(C) Concierge Medicine Today/The DPC Journal
REPLAY PASS | Nov 12-Dec 31, 2020 | ON DEMAND INDUSTRY EVENTS
Replay EVERY Session of CMF 2020-2021 On-Demand! Over 3 years of Concierge Medicine and Subscription-based conference sessions! Renews annually. Cancel anytime. SAVE $425 vs Monthly | ($47.99/Mo. OR, $149.99/yr)
Master Class: Grow Your Practice, 101 Edu
New Industry Webinar Series w/ MASTER MIND GROUP
Benefits to Communities and Doctors When A Hospital Implements a Concierge Medicine or Executive Health Programs + Examples + New 3-Part Webinar Series
Our Upcoming Edu. Webinars
Replay EVERY Session of CMF 2020-2021 On-Demand! Over 3 years of Concierge Medicine and Subscription-based conference sessions! Renews annually. Cancel anytime. SAVE $425 vs Monthly | ($47.99/Mo. OR, $149.99/yr)
2021: MEMBERSHIP FEE TRENDS IN CONCIERGE MEDICINE
The DocPreneur Leadership Podcast | New Each Week!
Accounting Terminology Every Doctor Should Know
GRAPHIC EDU. | The Free Market Healthcare Delivery Family Tree
All New On-Demand Course | #FORDoctors
Enroll in CMTs "FOR DOCTORS FORUM" - a Virtual online community for Doctors -- with online/on-demand courses and interactive video training, marketing and growing your healthcare practice with insight from YOUR PEERS, physician leadership and business advice, surveys, checklists, polls and insight on how to thrive as an entrepreneurial Physician -- Sign Up Free, Browse Courses -- Start Growing Today ... FREE!
Interior Design In Medicine
HOSPITALS, HOSPITALITY and the CONCIERGE PHYSICIAN
Survey: What items should you include in this unique gift from Doctor to Patient/Family? List your ideas/items below. VIEW Answers HERE
INDUSTRY PHYSICIAN & NETWORKING COMMUNITY ONLINE FORUM
Watch Now and Join Your Peers in Our New Online Forum, The Concierge Medicine Forum ... (JOIN FREE HERE)
BOOK | Latest Edition | Free Shipping
NEW! Latest Edition - Over 700+ Pages of Education, Tips, Tools, Strategies and Insight Into Concierge Medicine and Building A Subscription-Based Healthcare Delivery Model ... LEARN MORE ...
LATEST ANALYSIS | INDUSTRY OBSERVATIONS
The Subtle and Important Differences Between Concierge Medicine and DPC.
Industry Stats and Trends
HISTORY of CM
ANALYSIS | INFOGRAPHIC EDU.
Combo Graphic Edu. (C) 2021 Concierge Medicine Today/The DPC Journal
Latest Stories
Discount BOOK Bundles!
NEW ONLINE COURSE | Patient Loyalty (New!)
Enroll in CMTs "FOR DOCTORS FORUM" - a Virtual online community for Doctors -- with online/on-demand courses and interactive video training, marketing and growing your healthcare practice with insight from YOUR PEERS, physician leadership and business advice, surveys, checklists, polls and insight on how to thrive as an entrepreneurial Physician -- Sign Up Free, Browse Courses -- Start Growing Today ... (Free Trial!)
LINKEDin FORUM
TOP 20 WEB SITES IN CONCIERGE CARE | 2020
Concierge Medicine Today
Concierge Medicine Today (CMT) is a news and information organization and the Concierge Medicine and Private Medicine industry’s oldest international trade publication for the Concierge Medicine and Membership Medicine marketplace.
CMT is the online destination for businesses, consumers, physicians, legislators, researchers and other stakeholders to learn about the history of this industry, various business aspects of the marketplace, trends, breaking news and more that drives the conversation that Concierge Medicine, Private Medicine and free market healthcare delivery is creating on a national and international level.
Jack Marquis has more than forty years’ experience in business, tax and health law. He founded the firm’s concierge medicine practice and has helped physicians across the country establish these practices. Recently he was named 2013 Tax Lawyer of the Year in the Grand Rapids area by the Best Lawyers in America publication. Tel: 616-396-3054 http://www.wnj.com
I. Introduction.
Concierge medicine has gained considerable traction over the last decade. Hundreds of physicians have started some form of such practices, and there are certainly many more to come. This article is about one such form and the central legal issue it faces.Few have ever been thrilled with the word “concierge” to describe a physician’s practice. Indeed, soon after the creation of the first national concierge medicine organization in mid-2003 (the American Society of Concierge Physicians (“ASCP”)), its name was changed to remove the dreaded word.1 Unfortunately, descriptors of complex things are usually more valuable as short-hand names than as working definitions, so it is not hard to see why the word “concierge” has stuck and is now used almost universally2 as a very loose way of referring to a physician practice that restricts its patient population to those able and willing to pay pre-determined periodic sums directly to the physician.One virtue of such an imprecise but convenient moniker in this context is that there are so many variations and permutations of concierge practices that any effort to find a good, convenient definition that might apply to all types of concierge medicine would be impossible. But one effort to rebrand a particular type is having some success, and that type is the subject of this article. In 2006, when Washington State was considering adopting legislation to control concierge practices,3 the proponents decided to adopt the word “direct” to describe the type of concierge medicine they wanted the legislation to permit. The word “direct” does not have the same negative connotations as the word “concierge,” and it has the further incidental advantage of accurately describing the essential characteristic of these practices.
II. What is a “direct” practice?
A “direct” practice is one where the patient pays a pre-determined periodic fee directly to the physician in exchange for the physician’s promise to care for the patient at no additional charge.
There are, of course, some variations on this theme, but this is the essential element common to all direct practices.A typical attribute of a direct practice is that the physician has opted out of Medicare. The reason for this is that Medicare, of course, controls how much a physician may charge for “covered services,” and charging a Medicare patient a predetermined flat fee for future medical services would almost certainly violate these billing limits. The Medicare billing rules could also prohibit a non-opted out physician from operating a practice in which her non-Medicare patients are “direct” patients but her Medicare patients are not. These “hybrid” direct practices have to deal with the Medicare billing rule that prohibits a physician from billing Medicare an amount greater than the amount he usually charges for the same services to non-Medicare patients.4 These billing restrictions cause virtually all direct-practice physicians to opt out of Medicare.5
III. What is the central legal issue with direct practices?
It is now common to classify concierge practices as either “fee for non-covered services” (“FNCS”) practices or direct practices. The one factor that distinguishes one from the other is that in a direct practice the patient receives medical care without paying anything more than the predetermined periodic fee, while in an FNCS practice medical services are billed in the traditional fashion.6 This fundamental difference gives rise to the one major legal risk of direct practices: that they might be insurance.The theory behind this assertion is that, by accepting a predetermined fee in advance (the “premium”) in exchange for the promise to provide all the primary medical care the patient (the “insured”) needs during the term of the agreement, the physician (the “insurer”) is underwriting a risk. The best example of the official assertion of this principle is from the Maryland Insurance Commissioner, who in 2009 issued an opinion declaring that virtually all direct practices were subject to Maryland’s insurance code.7
Another example is the case of Dr. John Muney, where the New York State Insurance Commissioner (“NYIC”) asserted that Dr. Muney’s direct practice violated the New York insurance laws. Dr. Muney agreed to settle the dispute by agreeing to charge $33 per “sick visit,” a modification that in the Commissioner’s mind transformed his practice from an insurance company into a run-of-the-mill physician’s clinic.Implicit in the NYIC’s position and the eventual settlement of the matter was a concept that is instructive in contemplating the “risk” element that leads some to argue that direct practices should be regulated as insurance companies – the distinction between a “well visit” and a “sick visit.” Although Dr. Muney did not distinguish between the two, his practice, like virtually all direct practices, called for a predetermined periodic fee (in Dr. Muney’s case a monthly one) that entitled the patient to an unlimited number of visits. “Well visits” means “preventative” encounters with a physician or at least visits that do not arise because the patient is sick or injured. A “sick visit” is when the patient is sick or injured and needs treatment or advice, an event that is not volitional – the patient has no choice in the matter, as she would if she were to decide to visit the physician for a preventative examination or discussion (that is, a “well visit”).
Apparently the only part of Dr. Muney’s arrangement that was offensive to the NYIC was that which allowed the patient, when sick or injured, to visit the physician an unlimited number of times without any further payment. In a March 6, 2009, letter to Dr. Muney’s attorney, the NYIC restated the settlement terms that had been reached with Dr. Muney and drew the distinction between “those services stemming from non-fortuitous events” (well visits) that were included in the Muney package and “those services stemming from fortuitous events [sick visits] that require an additional fee.” This additional fee, which the Commissioner required for the “fortuitous” visits, was $33 per visit. The Commissioner also noted Dr. Muney’s agreement to limit the “$33 sick visits” to fifteen per year, after which the patient would be expected to pay the regular, non-discounted rate for an office visit.Clearly the NYIC was not concerned with “well visits,” and rightly so. As hard as it might be to claim that a physician agreeing to treat a sick or injured patient for a predetermined, one-time fee is operating an insurance company, it is much harder to reach the same conclusion just because a physician agrees to see a patient as often as the patient likes to discuss matters of preventative health.
IV. Are direct practices really insurance?
On December 19, 2008, the Maryland Insurance Commissioner (“MIC”) held a public hearing to determine whether concierge medicine practices in Maryland “constitute the business of insurance.” The conclusion as to direct practices was that in almost all cases they were, subject to a few modest qualifications. Taking off on the idiom “the devil is in the details,” the MIC concluded that8 one way or the other any determination would have to be made on a case-by-case basis because “the devil is in the contract” (between the physician and the patient).In order to examine the question of whether direct practices are indeed the “business of insurance,” let’s create an example of a prototype direct practice that would now certainly be considered insurance in Maryland.
Consider a direct practice of Dr. Martin, our hypothetical family physician. She agrees to provide her patients with all the family medicine services they need for the ensuing year in exchange for an up-front payment of $1,200 each. Dr. Martin has 400 patients, so her practice generates $480,000 a year from these flat fees, and she does not bill insurance companies or Medicare. Indeed, she has opted out of Medicare. If we assume that all the fees are collected on the first day of the year, Dr. Martin is holding $480,000 to start the year and has the obligation for that year to furnish her 400 patients with all the primary care she can personally provide.
FREE | CMT Webinar Event | Wednesday’s at 7-8pm EDT
Latest Discounts (Free Shipping!)
Our Best Selling Book Ever | Free Shipping!
NEW! Latest Edition - Over 700+ Pages of Education, Tips, Tools, Strategies and Insight Into Concierge Medicine and Building A Subscription-Based Healthcare Delivery Model ... LEARN MORE ...
New On-Demand Course Available!
A look into a form of Concierge Medicine called “Dignitary Medicine” (abb. DM or DPM)
Job Boards
2022-23 TOP Doctors Nominication Application
Join the National Directory of Concierge Medicine Physicians
Industry Best Practices | Online Courses
EMR Created By Doctors, FOR DOCTORS
Physicians | SELF-TEST (Free!)
BOOK SALE BUNDLE
The "DocPreneur Book BUNDLE" -- Our Most Popular Educational Resource BOOK BUNDLE -- DISCOUNTED, plus, FREE SHIPPING ... Click Here ...
2021 | HOSPITAL-BASED CONCIERGE CARE PROGRAMMING + EXAMPLES
BROWSE INDUSTRY EDU EVENTS & WEEKLY SEMINARS
NOV. 2020 100% Virtual Concierge Medicine FORUM - Online Conference -- FOR DOCTORS ... Learn More ...
Join CMTs All-New Concierge Medicine Forum | Instant Access
Replay EVERY Session of CMF 2020-2021 On-Demand! Over 3 years of Concierge Medicine and Subscription-based conference sessions! Renews annually. Cancel anytime. SAVE $425 vs Monthly | ($47.99/Mo. OR, $149.99/yr)
PHYSICIAN SURVEY | 2021
2020 Concierge Medicine Physician National Patient Engagement SURVEY ...
2021-2022 Annual Conference | Apply
Understanding the Math Behind Concierge Medicine’s Value Proposition.
Master Class: Doctor’s Guide to Media Relations & Public Speaking
WEEKLY WEBINARS and On-DEMAND COURSES | #FORDoctors
NEW ONLINE COURSE: Doctors Building A Culture of Hospitality
NEW! Latest Edition - Over 700+ Pages of Education, Tips, Tools, Strategies and Insight Into Concierge Medicine and Building A Subscription-Based Healthcare Delivery Model ... LEARN MORE ...
2021 | Atlanta, GA USA | Annual Conference
25+ Concierge Medicine Industry Statistics, Graphics and Trends, 2021.
2021 Industry Stats and Graphs About the Innovation Happening In the Concierge Medicine Industry
Math + History Lesson
INDUSTRY EVENTS & WEBINARS
(NEW) On Demand Online Courses For Doctors, Nurses, Medical Staff and PAs
CMT DOC FINDER
Searching For A Concierge Physician Who Is Accepting New Patients ... Hopefully, We Can Help ... Start Your Search Here ...
CMTs New Online MasterMind Community
SHOP ALL of OUR EDU RESOURCES
In-Depth ANALYSIS, 2021
JOIN OUR MASTER MIND GROUP(S)
NEW ONLINE COURSE | Webinars
Enroll in CMTs "FOR DOCTORS FORUM" - a Virtual online community for Doctors -- with online/on-demand courses and interactive video training, marketing and growing your healthcare practice with insight from YOUR PEERS, physician leadership and business advice, surveys, checklists, polls and insight on how to thrive as an entrepreneurial Physician -- Sign Up Free, Browse Courses -- Start Growing Today ... FREE!