Concierge Medicine Today

Man vs. Machine: No Contest, According to New Study that Shows Physicians Vastly Outperform Technology in Diagnostic Accuracy

41 percent of patients want to use technology for lab results access compared to only 18 percent of physicians. Also important to note: 61 percent of patients believe using an electronic patient portal improves their relationships with their physicians

SOURCE: https://specialdocs.com/physicians-diagnostic-accuracy/

Physicians won’t be surprised to learn that their experience and knowledge results in accurate diagnoses more than twice as often as computer algorithms. The results were published in a first of its kind study comparing human and computer diagnoses, originally published October 10, 2016 in JAMA Internal Medicine. The key takeaways: physicians who participated in the study achieved diagnostic accuracy 72 percent of the time compared to just 34 percent of the time recorded for digital devices. This difference was particularly noticeable when diagnosing severe and unusual conditions.

An overview can be found at HealthData Management. The full study is available on The JAMA Network, available to accountholders only. Read it here.

However, the role of technology in medicine continues to expand, and patients express a desire for more, not less, use of it on platforms such as electronic patient portals or as a way to gain immediate access to lab test results.

According to a recent Medscape report titled “Physician and Patient Attitudes Toward Technology in Medicine,” 41 percent of patients want to use technology for lab results access compared to only 18 percent of physicians. Also important to note: 61 percent of patients believe using an electronic patient portal improves their relationships with their physicians, while only 49 percent of physicians perceive the same benefit.

Physicians, what are your thoughts on these findings? Do you think electronic patient portals improve your relationships with your patients? Share your perspective with us on LinkedInTwitter or Facebook. We want to hear from you!

About

Founded in 2002, Specialdocs Consultants, LLC is a pioneer in transitioning traditional medical practices nationwide to independent, custom-designed concierge models. Our unique approach ensures that physicians retain autonomy, with their own names at the forefront of the practice. Specialdocs’ highly experienced staff, along with our reputation for success and integrity across the country, allows us to remain the leader in transitioning more physicians to this independent model than any other company. We provide all the essentials and ongoing support for a successful concierge medicine practice – patient communications, staff and physician training, accounting and membership fee processing, patient outreach and marketing programs, legal counsel – and we continue to support our physicians throughout the transition process and beyond.

SOURCE: https://specialdocs.com/physicians-diagnostic-accuracy/

One thought on “Man vs. Machine: No Contest, According to New Study that Shows Physicians Vastly Outperform Technology in Diagnostic Accuracy

  1. Nice study design from what I can tell from the synopsis on HDM. It was good that the authors used common symptom checker already available. I think this study tells us what lay persons and physicians already know… the grid through which fact are filtered is an important determinant in prioritizing meaningful information. Perspective and experience matters. Given the myriad of ways that humans experience and report symptoms, it will take sophisticated AI to mimic good medical decision-making.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: